← Insights

Comparing Limited Liability Companies and Joint Stock Companies: Choosing the Right Business Structure

By Daniel NguyenNovember 16, 20269 min read
Comparing Limited Liability Companies and Joint Stock Companies: Choosing the Right Business Structure

Compare limited liability companies and joint stock companies under the 2020 Enterprise Law: capital, governance, liability, and capital mobilization — to help you choose the right structure from the start.

This English version is translated from the Vietnamese original. In case of any discrepancy, the Vietnamese version prevails.

Comparing limited liability companies (LLC) and joint-stock companies to choose the right business structure when establishing a company is a question that most business owners, investors, and chief accountants must face from the very first step. This decision directly affects governance structure, capital mobilization capacity, degree of legal liability, and operating costs throughout the business lifecycle. The article below provides detailed analysis of each criterion based on the Law on Enterprises 2020 (No. 59/2020/QH14) to help you make an appropriate choice.

Before comparing, it is necessary to clearly understand the legal definition of each business type to avoid confusion when designing the enterprise structure.

Limited Liability Company (LLC)

The Law on Enterprises 2020, Article 74 — Single-member Limited Liability Company provides:

"A single-member limited liability company is an enterprise owned by an organization or individual as the owner (hereinafter referred to as the company owner). The company owner bears responsibility for the company's debts and other financial obligations within the scope of the company's charter capital."

Both single-member limited liability companies and limited liability companies with two or more members have legal personality from the date they receive a Business Registration Certificate and may not issue shares, except in cases of conversion to a joint-stock company as provided by law. The charter capital of a single-member LLC is the total value of assets that the owner commits to contribute and is recorded in the company's charter; for LLCs with two or more members, charter capital is the total value of capital contributions that members commit to contribute and is recorded in the company's charter.

Joint-Stock Company (JSC)

Article 111 — Joint-Stock Company provides:

"Charter capital is divided into equal parts called shares; shareholders may be organizations or individuals; the minimum number of shareholders is 03 and there is no maximum limit; shareholders are responsible for the company's debts and other financial obligations only within the scope of capital they have contributed to the enterprise; shareholders have the right to freely transfer their shares to others, except in cases provided for in Clause 3 of Article 120 and Clause 1 of Article 127 of this Law."

Joint-stock companies have the right to issue shares, bonds, and other types of securities — this is a significant advantage over LLCs when an enterprise needs to mobilize large-scale capital.

Comparison table of LLC and JSC by main criteria

Criteria

LLC (Single Member)

LLC (Two or More Members)

Joint-Stock Company

Number of owners/shareholders

1 (individual or organization)

From 2 to 50 members

Minimum 3, no maximum limit

Asset liability

Within the scope of charter capital

Within the scope of capital contribution

Within the scope of capital contributed

Share issuance

Not permitted (except upon conversion to JSC)

Not permitted

Permitted to issue shares, bonds, and other securities

Capital transfer

Owner has full discretion

Must offer to existing members first (per charter and law)

Shareholders free to transfer (except cases restricted by law)

Management structure

Company President or Members' Meeting + Director/General Director

Members' Meeting + President of Members' Meeting + Director/General Director

General Shareholders' Meeting + Board of Directors + Supervisory Board (or Audit Committee) + Director/General Director

Legal representative

May be one or more persons per charter

May be one or more persons per charter

Chairman of Board of Directors and/or Director/General Director (per Article 137)

Capital mobilization capacity

Owner contributes additional capital, raises borrowed capital, issues bonds as regulated; may convert business type

Increase capital from existing members, accept new members, borrow capital, issue bonds as regulated

More flexible through share issuance, bonds, and other securities as regulated

Transparency/information disclosure

Lower requirements

Lower requirements

Higher requirements, especially for public companies

Legal personality

Yes, from the date of issuance of Business Registration Certificate

Yes, from the date of issuance of Business Registration Certificate

Yes, from the date of issuance of Business Registration Certificate

Governance structure — the key difference between LLC and JSC

Governance structure is a practical factor that directly affects decision-making speed and operating costs.

For LLCs with two or more members, Article 54, Clause 1 provides for a minimum structure consisting of: Members' Meeting, President of Members' Meeting, Director or General Director. For a single-member LLC where the owner is an organization, it may choose either the model of Company President + Director/General Director or Members' Meeting + Director/General Director (Article 79, Clause 1).

For joint-stock companies, Article 137 allows the choice of one of two models:

  • Model with Supervisory Board: General Shareholders' Meeting + Board of Directors + Supervisory Board + Director/General Director. Where the company has fewer than 11 shareholders and organizational shareholders own less than 50% of total shares, the Supervisory Board is not mandatory.

  • Model with Audit Committee: General Shareholders' Meeting + Board of Directors + Director/General Director. In this model, at least 20% of Board members must be independent members and there must be an Audit Committee under the Board of Directors.

Practice shows: early-stage startups typically choose LLCs because of the lean structure and fast decision-making. When needing to raise capital from investment funds or expand shareholders, the enterprise will consider converting to a joint-stock company.

Rights of members/shareholders — who gets more?

Members of the Members' Meeting in an LLC have basic rights per Article 49, Clause 1, including: attending meetings and voting with votes corresponding to capital contribution, receiving profit distribution and remaining assets upon dissolution, right of first offer when the company increases charter capital, and right to sue for civil liability against managers.

With joint-stock companies, shareholders enjoy the right of free share transfer (except cases restricted by law), right to profit distribution according to shares owned, and notably the ability to participate in the securities market if the company is listed — this is a significant liquidity advantage over capital contributions in LLCs.

This is a legal risk many enterprises overlook. Article 75, Clause 4 of the Law on Enterprises 2020 clearly provides for single-member LLCs as follows:

"The company owner bears responsibility with all of his/her assets for the company's financial obligations and damage caused by failure to contribute, insufficient contribution, or late contribution of charter capital as provided in this Article."

For members of LLCs with two or more members, Article 50, Clause 1 provides the obligation to: contribute sufficient and timely capital as committed, bear responsibility for the company's debts and other financial obligations within the scope of capital contributed to the company, except in special cases per Clause 2 and Clause 4 of Article 47.

For joint-stock companies, shareholders must pay in full for shares they registered to purchase within 90 days from the date of issuance of the Business Registration Certificate, except as otherwise provided by law. Failure to pay in full subjects the shareholder to liability per Article 113 of the Law on Enterprises 2020; the company must simultaneously perform procedures to adjust charter capital and the list of founding shareholders as regulated.

A common practical risk: enterprises register high charter capital to create credibility but have not actually contributed sufficient capital within the legal deadline. If disputes occur or inspections are conducted, the owner/member may have to bear personal liability exceeding the registered charter capital.

Article 12, Clause 2 of the Law on Enterprises 2020 provides: both LLCs and joint-stock companies may have one or more legal representatives. The company charter specifies the number, position, and rights and obligations of each person.

A noteworthy point: if a company has more than one legal representative but the division of rights and obligations is not clearly defined in the charter, then each legal representative is fully authorized to represent before third parties, and all legal representatives bear joint and several liability for damage caused to the enterprise.

Per Clause 2 of Article 137 of the Law on Enterprises 2020, a joint-stock company may have one or more legal representatives. Where the company has only one legal representative, the Chairman of the Board of Directors or Director/General Director is the legal representative as per the company charter. If the charter has no other provision, the Chairman of the Board of Directors is the legal representative. Where the company has more than one legal representative, the Chairman of the Board of Directors and Director/General Director are ex officio legal representatives of the company.

Which business type should you choose — depending on specific circumstances?

There is no absolute answer. The optimal choice depends on the goals, scale, and strategy of each enterprise:

  • Choose single-member LLC when: you want full control, simple governance structure, do not need to raise capital from outside sources in the short term, or the enterprise is a 100% subsidiary of a corporation.

  • Choose LLC with two or more members when: you have 2 to 50 founding members, want tight control over the member list (due to more restricted capital transfer), and have no plans to list.

  • Choose joint-stock company when: you need to raise capital from multiple investors, plan to list on a stock exchange, or want flexible ownership structure with free share transfer capability. This is also the mandatory form if the enterprise aims to become a public company.

An important practical note: enterprises can completely convert between the two types when meeting the requirements regarding the number of members or shareholders as provided in the Law on Enterprises 2020. However, the conversion process requires synchronized updates of both internal documentation and registration documents — a step that many enterprises overlook, leading to discrepancies between actual operations and legal records, potentially creating significant risks in disputes or M&A transactions.

A&D Law Firm helps you choose correctly from the start

Choosing a business type is not just an administrative procedure — it is a legal decision affecting your entire business journey. The team of lawyers at A&D Law Firm has experience advising on enterprise structure for both domestic and foreign investors, from establishment to restructuring and business conversion. If you are hesitating between an LLC and a joint-stock company, please contact us for analysis specific to your situation.

This article is for informational reference only regarding general business law and does not replace formal legal advice for specific cases. Legal regulations may change over time. Please contact a lawyer at A&D Law Firm for advice appropriate to your actual circumstances.

Need legal advice? Contact us now. Hotline: 0896868989

Share this article:

Need legal advice?

Our team at A&D Law Firm is ready to assist.

Free Consultation

Frequently asked questions

Related articles

Business legal matters that enterprises should review before Tet 2027

Business legal matters that enterprises should review before Tet 2027

New 2026 Personal Allowance: What Salary Requires Personal Income Tax Filing?

New 2026 Personal Allowance: What Salary Requires Personal Income Tax Filing?

Commercial Contract Review: 12-Point Checklist Before Signing

Commercial Contract Review: 12-Point Checklist Before Signing

Ready to Protect Your Business?

Schedule a free consultation with our legal team and discover how A&D Law Firm can be your strategic legal partner.

Schedule Free ConsultationOr call us: +84 89 68 68 989